Difference between revisions of "HVOR"
(→HVOR ANNAR) |
|||
Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
==HVOR ANNAR== | ==HVOR ANNAR== | ||
− | When "(hvor) öðrum" is clearly the object of a preposition and "hvor" and "öðrum" appear adjacent, they are grouped together as a bare NP and under that hvor has its own bare NP | + | When "(hvor) öðrum" is clearly the object of a preposition and "hvor" and "öðrum" appear adjacent, they are grouped together as a bare NP and under that hvor has its own bare NP. This may not be a good analysis but it allows us to enforce case agreement inside NPs (as opposed to not having hvor project an NP). |
<pre> | <pre> |
Revision as of 11:36, 28 September 2010
'hvor', as in hvor hjá öðrum 'each with the other'. Treat the whole thing as NP-ADV. This parse is used *only* where *neither* "hvor" or "öðrum" are an argument of the verb *and* "öðrum" is inside a PP.
(NP-ADV (NP (Q-N hvor-hvor)) (PP (P hjá-hjá) (NP (OTHER-D öðrum-annar))))
If *neither* "hvor" or "öðrum" are an argument of the verb but there is no PP involved, then "hvor" and "öðrum" do not project their own NPs.
(NP-ADV (Q-N hvor-hvor) (OTHER-D öðrum-annar))
However, the above construction can also occur in such a way as to force "hvor" and the other constituent to project their own NPs. This parse is used as a last resort, however.
(CP-THT-PRN-1 (C að-að) (IP-SUB (IP-SUB (NP-SBJ (PRO-N hann-hann)) (VBDI þóttist-þykja) (IP-INF (VB sjá-sjá) (NP-OB1 (NS-A hrafna-hrafn) (NUM-A tvo-tveir)))) (CONJP (CONJ og-og) (IP-SUB (NP-SBJ *pro*) (VBDI kváðu-kveða) (NP-OB1 (D-A þetta-þessi)) (NP-ADV (NP (NP-POS (PRO-A sitt-sinn)) (N-A orð-orð)) (NP (Q-N hvor-hvor)))))))
When "(hvor) öðrum" is clearly the object (or "hvor" is ambiguous between being part of the object or a floated quantifier) and "hvor" and "öðrum" appear adjacent, they are grouped together as an NP constituent with the appropriate clause-level argument label, as below. NOTE: This is done regardess of the case-marking of "hvor".
( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ (PRO-N þeir-hann)) (VBDI rituðu-rita) (NP-TMP (NS-D stundum-stundum)) (NP-OB1 (Q-N hvor-hvor) (OTHER-D öðrum-annar)))
HVOR ANNAR
When "(hvor) öðrum" is clearly the object of a preposition and "hvor" and "öðrum" appear adjacent, they are grouped together as a bare NP and under that hvor has its own bare NP. This may not be a good analysis but it allows us to enforce case agreement inside NPs (as opposed to not having hvor project an NP).
(PP (P við) (NP (NP (Q-N hvor-hvor)) (OTHER-A annan-annar)))